Heat Cables vs. Fixing the Attic: The Ice Dam Questions Spokane Googles Every November
Will adding insulation stop ice dams?
Every November, the week the first snow sticks, Home Depot sells out of heat cable in Spokane. Every January, we remove ice dams from roofs that have heat cable on them. Here's what's going on, in the form of the questions people actually type.
Do heat cables prevent ice dams?
No. They melt a channel through the ice so some meltwater can escape. The ice dam still forms on either side of the channel, the roof deck under the snow is still warm, and the cables run up your Avista bill every hour they're on. We routinely find dams two inches thick sitting directly on top of working heat cable.
Cables treat the symptom at the gutter. The cause is 30 feet up the slope, inside the attic.
Do icicles mean I have ice dams?
Icicles mean snow is melting on your roof while the air is below freezing. That melt is coming from heat leaving your house through the attic. Small icicles on a sunny south-facing eave after a warm afternoon are normal. Thick icicles on a north eave, icicles behind the gutter, or icicles on a cloudy 20°F day mean your roof deck is warm and you have a dam forming or already formed. What icicles are telling you →
Why does my house get ice dams and my neighbor's doesn't?
Same snow, same temperature, different attic. The house with ice dams has heat getting into the attic, usually through air leaks at the ceiling: can lights, the hatch, a bath fan dumping into the attic, top plates, the furnace flue chase. That heat warms the roof deck above freezing while the eaves (which hang out past the heated house) stay cold. Snow melts on the warm part, runs down, and refreezes on the cold part. The dam is the line between the two.
Your neighbor's attic is either better sealed or has so little insulation that it's just as cold as outside, which means a brutal heating bill but no dams. Neither of you should copy the other.
Will adding insulation stop ice dams?
Only if the air leaks are sealed first. Insulation slows heat conduction; it does nothing to stop warm air moving through gaps. Blow 12 more inches onto a leaky ceiling and the leaks are still there, delivering warm, wet air to the roof deck, now buried where no one can fix them. This is also why unsealed attics get frost on the sheathing: the science of attic condensation is the same physics as ice dams, from the inside.
The order that works: seal the ceiling plane, correct the ventilation, then insulate to R-60.
How much do heat cables cost vs. fixing the attic?
Cables: roughly $300–800 in materials for a typical eave run, plus installation, plus electricity every winter, plus replacement every 5–10 years, plus the dams you still get. The attic fix is a one-time job that also lowers the heating bill, stops attic frost, and makes the house more comfortable. We put the actual numbers and the energy math in Fix Ice Dams Permanently: What It Costs.
Should I rake the snow off my roof?
It helps in the short term and doesn't hurt if you stay on the ground with a roof rake. It does nothing about why the snow is melting. If you find yourself raking after every storm, your attic is telling you something.
Can I fix ice dams in the middle of winter?
The attic work, yes. Air sealing and insulation happen from inside, so a 15°F day doesn't stop us. Our ice dam attic jobs are one day for a clean attic and two if the existing insulation is wet or moldy and has to come out first. Removing an existing dam from the roof is a steam job and a separate service; we'll tell you who to call for that if you're actively leaking.
When do heat cables make sense?
Two situations. First, a specific architectural trouble spot, like a valley over a cantilevered bay or a low-slope dormer, where even a perfectly sealed attic can't keep the deck cold. Second, as a temporary measure to get through this winter if the attic work has to wait. In both cases they're a supplement to a fixed attic, not a substitute for one.
Does insurance cover ice dam damage?
Usually the resulting water damage to ceilings and insulation is covered as a sudden loss; the ice dam itself and the attic fix usually aren't. Document everything, and get the attic corrected before the adjuster's repair is finished, or you'll be filing again next year.
Book before it snows
The attic work is the same in November as in January, but November has open calendar dates and January doesn't. Same-day inspection: insulationspokane.com/inspections or (509) 351-2811.
Everything Attic. Except Bats. We're Terrified of Bats.
Follow us













